I have received nearly a dozen complaints about my last post. Many have read into my post things that I did not say and overlooked other things that I did say. I would like to address each complaint here.
The ECWR website has never referred anyone to Goss!
The ECWR website has never referred anyone to Goss!
Answer: It does refer people to Goss. You can see for yourself by locating the fifth resource listed under Book Reviews at http://ecwr.org/resources/the-bible-and-homosexuality.html, as of January 27, 2012.
The ECWR website does NOT refer to Queering Christ or the quote in your post.
The ECWR website does NOT refer to Queering Christ or the quote in your post.
Answer: In my post, I did not say that the ECWR website includes a reference to Queering Christ or the quote in my last post. I said that the ECWR website "positively refers" people to Goss as a resource. I think that is dangerous, and I will explain why I feel so strongly about this in the next question.
Why are you freaking out over one mention of Goss on the ECWR website?
Answer:
I run across a wide spectrum of individuals who experience SSA. Some
lack much exposure to faith. Others are LGBT persons who identify as gay
Christians. Others are SSA strugglers who believe that acting upon
their sexual inclinations would be sinful. When my ministry can in any way nourish faith identity and provide
pastoral care, that help is readily available to this spectrum of
individuals. To be clear, the "help" is NOT assisting persons to
change from gay to straight (which I believe is very elusive), but rather ensuring that they have access to excellent
support and acceptance within the evangelical church. Particularly teens who are being bullied and/or are experiencing suicidality.
In my work, I sometimes
encounter gay Christians and seekers who say they will
never seek a home in the evangelical church. I have
referred some of them to ECWR. Why? For one reason: if they cannot
seek Christ within traditional evangelicalism, I want to
encourage them to keep seeking Christ. This is one venue to do that. So,
as you can imagine, I have a tremendous responsibility to those who I
have referred to ECWR. I felt it was important for me to publicly clarify that
Goss' work is not something I want to refer anyone to. That is the only
motivation for my last post. As I said in the post, I am not looking for a debate. I feel strongly that Goss can severely damage a young person's search for Jesus Christ - especially young people without a faith/church background.
Why are you holding ECWR responsible for the Goss quote?
Answer: I think we all are held responsible for nearly every word we say or fail to say on a topic as challenging as homosexuality. I will illustrate my answer to your question like this: if Fred Phelps ever writes a book on grace or love, will I include it on Lead Them Home's website? Absolutely not, unless by some far-fetched chance his rhetoric truly demonstrates a radical change in heart toward LGBT people. Even in such an unlikely case, I would be held accountable by many for every horrible act of hate that Phelps ever committed. I place Goss in a similar category. He defames Christ to such a degree that ECWR should be cautious about placing a referral to him on their website. It is their choice. This is my view.
Why are you holding ECWR responsible for the Goss quote?
Answer: I think we all are held responsible for nearly every word we say or fail to say on a topic as challenging as homosexuality. I will illustrate my answer to your question like this: if Fred Phelps ever writes a book on grace or love, will I include it on Lead Them Home's website? Absolutely not, unless by some far-fetched chance his rhetoric truly demonstrates a radical change in heart toward LGBT people. Even in such an unlikely case, I would be held accountable by many for every horrible act of hate that Phelps ever committed. I place Goss in a similar category. He defames Christ to such a degree that ECWR should be cautious about placing a referral to him on their website. It is their choice. This is my view.
I cannot believe you would criticize Dr. Ralph Blair for his work!
Answer: I did not criticize Dr. Blair. I never mentioned his name in my post. However, I was privileged to be contacted by him about my post. We had a very cordial conversation via email. I will keep our discussion confidential, but I think it is fine to say that we both passionately agree that Goss is not a healthy resource for anyone. He was quite kind, and our conversation was wonderfully helpful.
Dr. Blair can be found at http://www.ecinc.org. ECINC and ECWR are not related even though both were founded by Dr. Blair. I never attributed anything in my last post to either ECINC or Dr. Blair - I attributed the Goss referral to ECWR.
I hope these are helpful clarifications. Please feel free to contact me if you have further concerns. Thank you very much, Bill
JOIN THE CONVERSATION: To add your feedback, simply click the red comments link below. You may elect to comment as "Anonymous." Share this article on Facebook, Twitter, Buzz or by email.